Tidbits: My Fair Lady

In preparation for seeing the TCM Big Screen Classics 55th Anniversary showing of My Fair Lady (1964), I cast around for some trivia about the cast. Controversy about the leading roles abounds. Still, the resulting film garnered the following Oscar wins at the 1965 Academy Awards:

  1. Best Picture – Jack L. Warner
  2. Best Actor in a Leading Role – Rex Harrison
  3. Best Director – George Cukor
  4. Best Cinematography, Color – Harry Stradling Sr.
  5. Best Art Direction-Set Decoration, Color – Gene Allen, Cecil Beaton, George James Hopkins
  6. Best Costume Design, Color – Cecil Beaton
  7. Best Sound – George Groves (Warner Bros. SSD)
  8. Best Music, Scoring of Music, Adaptation or Treatment – André Previn

Now, on to some My Fair Lady casting hubbub courtesy of IMBD.

My Fair Lady Poster

Casting Professor Henry Higgins
Jack L. Warner originally didn’t want Rex Harrison to reprise his stage role as Higgins for the film version, since he had seen Cleopatra (1963) and thought the actor looked too old to be believable as Audrey Hepburn’s love interest. Peter O’Toole was considered for the role of Prof. Higgins, but his salary demands were too high. Harrison responded in a letter to Warner Bros. that he had only looked old as Gaio Giulio Cesare because he had been playing an epileptic at the end of his life, and after sending some publicity photographs of himself–minus his toupee–he was eventually cast.

To me, this role just belongs to Rex Harrison, and I was privileged as a child to see him play it on the stage. But, Peter O’Toole is an indeed an intriguing choice.

When asked why he turned down the role of Henry Higgins, Cary Grant remarked that his original manner of speaking was much closer to Eliza Dolittle. Cary Grant told Jack L. Warner that not only would he not play Henry Higgins, but if Rex Harrison was not cast in the role, he wouldn’t even go see the picture.

Even though I am a mega Cary Grant fan, I don’t see him in the role. I’m with Cary, this part belongs to Rex Harrison.

Casting Eliza Doolittle
The role of Eliza Doolittle was originally played on Broadway by Julie Andrews. However, she was denied the role because the film’s producers didn’t think she was “known” enough as a film actress. Audrey Hepburn apparently believed that Julie Andrews should have played Eliza Doolittle in the film, but was told by Jack L. Warner that she wouldn’t be cast even if Audrey turned the role down. Audrey Hepburn herself revealed years later that had she turned down the role of Eliza, the next actress to be offered it would not have been Julie Andrews but Elizabeth Taylor, who wanted it desperately.

While I would love to have seen Julie Andrews in the role of Eliza Doolittle in the film, I do have great affection for Audrey Hepburn’s portrayal. Her transformation is stunning to behold. And I can’t picture Elizabeth Taylor in the role, talented though she was.

Image may be subject to copyright.

Kami Spangenberg

About Kami Spangenberg

Kami Spangenberg is one-half of Classic Couple. She loves classic movies and shares that passion with others as a film blogger and as lead curriculum developer at Classic Couple Academy. While it's hard to play favorites, films topping her all-time, must-see list are: It Happened One Night, Ball of Fire, His Girl Friday, Libeled Lady, My Sister Eileen, The Philadelphia Story, The Thin Man, The Shop Around the Corner and The Way We Were. Oh, and The Outlaw Josey Wales. She has attended the TCM Classic Film Festival six times in LA as well as the 2020 TCM Festival Special Home Edition from her couch. She is honored to have her writing featured from time to time on TheFilmDetective.com. She also contributes content to IMDb.com to raise awareness of classic movies.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>